Home Up
  The Rule of Law  



False Piety
A Just Society
The Rule of Law
Possibilities I
Possibilities II






24"x 54"    Diptych     Oil on Canvas   (2002)                                                                                          $2485


Click here to see details and text from painting


The Legal System and Prison Systems

The findings of the TRC hearings on South Africa’s legal institutions concluded that judges exercised limited independence and therefore did not function as an effective check and balance to the other two branches of government.  Adherence to the rule of law essentially served as a powerful legitimizing influence for the exercise of authority.

Justices typically invoked parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law which are premised on a system of representative government that is fundamentally representative of all the people subject to that parliament’s laws.  That was not the case in South Africa prior to 1994 since parliament was only elected by the white population.

“The legal profession unwittingly connived in the legislative and executive pursuit of unjustice.”  

TRC, Special Hearings, Findings in Final Report, 1998.

“The mere fact that you were black meant your clothing was different, as if the weather treated you differently.  Your food was different, as if you became hungry in a different way.  The food was a problem because you were with comrades ... who could actually eat bread.  Even the amount of sugar in your porridge was different: the blacks got a teaspoon, the others two.”       

 Testimony by Mr. Andrew Masondo, describing conditions on Robben Island.

       TRC, Special Hearings, Final Report, 1998.


The South African judiciary produced the highest capital punishment rate in the western world by the mid 1980’s and the execution rate overwhelmingly impacted black males.

Between 1960-1994 more than 2500 people were hung in South Africa.  Of these 95% were black and all of them were sentenced by white judges.

Between 1976-1985, 1,154 people were executed and between 1960-1990 80,000 were detained without charges.  Of these nearly 20,000 were tortured in detention and 73 died while in police custody.

         TRC, Final Report, 1998.


   Back Home Up Next